The Boogiepop franchise is an interesting oddity: it is a fairly large and expansive set of light novels in Japan but never really crossed the ocean or anywhere else. The novels have sold over 2 million copies in Japan in 2000. That’s quite a large number given the time. In a much larger market (and I mean much larger), everything Haruhi has sold a “mere” 8 million. I know that sounds like a lot, but when you consider the cultural impact Haruhi has, you get a sense of how important Boogiepop is to the light novel landscape. In fact, it’s sometimes argued that the light novel trend originated from Boogiepop.
What followed was a foray of this franchise into the anime landscape. MADHOUSE, pretty much a household producer name (Chobits, Death Note, Monster, Paranoia Agent, Trigun…they’ve got a long list of greatest hits), took it upon themselves to bring the franchise’s unique narrative style (more on this later) to the television screen. And Boogiepop Phantom is the result. The studio went to Takashi Watanabe for direction. He showed success in the Slayers franchise and would later tag his name to many other projects (He became part of the Shakugan no Shana franchise as the director and Death Note as a storyboard writer). For sound they asked the prolific Yota Tsuruoka to step in. He also has a massive resume today. Top billing probably goes to the Clannad franchise but you come real close to saying he’s done pretty much every anime you know.
Okay. Let’s start off with this: you won’t fully understand much of the main story in Boogiepop Phantom without reading two light novels first: Boogiepop and Others and Boogiepop at Dawn. The anime connects the two events and concludes the events of the former. Instead of a traditional description of the back story, I’ll explain what happened before to a level where one can understand the events.
Nagi Kirima, a schoolgirl, grew at an abnormally fast rate and was dying as a result. The hospital admitted her and tried to take care of her and her condition. Shinpei Kuroda, an agent for the Towa Organization, befriended her. He went behind the organization’s back and administered a drug to Kirima to prevent her from growing at abnormal pace. The organization executed him soon after.
Dr. Kisugi, a resident general doctor, found remains of the Towa Organization’s drug. She tested it on rats and found it created incredible powers in the subjects. So she did the natural thing and tried it on herself. Naturally, things go sideways and she becomes a composite human. Composite humans are kind of nuts most of the time and she becomes a mass murderer, killing strong-willed girls because she was addicted to their fear. Kirima, investigating the murders, found her and with the aid of Boogiepop, the whispered “angel of death”, killed the insane doctor.
A monster named Manticore, escaped one month ago. It is a failed clone of a highly evolved alien, Echoes. Echoes, sent by its race to elvaulate humans, monitored earth and could only repeat what was said to it as a way of limiting its power. The Towa Organization captured it and tried to clone it…unsuccessfully. That created Manticore. Anyways, Manticore killed a normal schoolgirl named Minako Yurihara and assumed her identity. During this time, another school student named Masami Saotome discovered this switch and, instead of killing Saotome, struck a deal with him: the two would addict students to an addictive drug named Type S which would enslave the user to the distributor of the drug. Then Manticore would eat the individuals for substanance once the experiment concluded. Echoes the Towa Organization to find the Manticore and met Kirima, who at this point is very much aloof and on the outside of traditional society. Saotome and Manticore, realizing they are being investigated and chased, set a trap for them. Echoes is critically injured in the fight and, in a final attempt to get rid of the fiend, turns itself into a pillar of light. The pillar destroys Manticore with the assistance of Boogiepop and Saotome, having fallen in love with Manticore, kills himself by jumping into the pillar.
The events of Boogiepop Phantom deal with the events arising from the pillar of light. One month after the fight, the entire city is covered in a strong electromagnetic field and a large aurora.
This is really as far as I can describe the narrative without giving anything away. But I can describe the narrative style. The light novels take a vignette approach to the narrative and show you a very short story focusing on one character. Then it’ll shift its focus in the next section. And then another character. And so on and so on. Boogiepop Phantom continues this tradition; every episode follows a specific character and follows their adventure through the supernatural events that overtake this unnamed city. Each character has their own troubles and some react more positively than others to the situation. The grand sum of all these side stories is a greater narrative that is not directly created and a climax that is not directly built until it reveals itself to us all.
And I love every second of it. This form of storytelling may feel a little meandering and disoriented at times but they effectively tell a narrative in a unique manner. But why do this? It makes the narrative even more interesting through the mystery. This occurs in multiple regards. First and foremost is the anime’s main narrative. We are treated to a shot of the pillar of light mentioned above. It knocks out all the electronics in the entire city for a second before everything restarts as if nothing happened. That seeds the question “how is this important?”. And this question slowly rises and creates further questions as the narrative progresses. This pull is a major driving force of the narrative.
Second in mystery is the interrelation of each narrative. Virtually every story connects to another. For example, there is a creepy guy in episode 1 who seems mostly perverted. The next episode focuses on him and what is happening to him. There is very little waste in this regard with only a couple of episodes focused on events that will not drive questions or imply certain answers. This seemingly tangential narrative begins pushing the viewer in certain directions and will feed the first mystery I listed above.
Finally, each character presents their own mystery. Each character you see is, at the core, a fairly blank slate. A few will be recurring from the light novels but largely this is an original cast. And after a few episodes you’ll know they all largely have deep-seeded mental issues in addition to their odd behaviour. Part of the mystery and attraction then becomes why this character acts this way in addition to what happens to them. In that regard, the psychology becomes a major aspect of the anime and the characters’ intentions become a major driving force.
The anime borders bleak and depressing at times. One of the major aspects of this anime is the negative influence of the supernatural; the fallout of the pillar of light is almost entirely negative. Many episodes end of a depressing note and one managed to break my heart completely before the first half the episode ended.
Interestingly, this bleak tone also wraps into a slight horror aspect in the anime. Boogiepop Phantom is hard to define with genres and most oft for the horror label. It isn’t entirely hard to see why as many character aspects are unsettling at best. See the picture above of a guy eating a yellow spider with intense determination. Uncertainty plays its way into many aspects and creates the same unsettling tone. The body count seems unusually high too with some fairly messy deaths. I’d personally describe the anime as more psychological than horror but these aspects certainly commonly attribute themselves to the horror genre.
What is probably the most impressive aspect of Boogiepop Phantom, for all the comments I’ve made above, is the ability to drive home focused messages. The characters often face similar root issues and their inability to influence such a problem becomes a key fatal flaw. I won’t go into much detail here but the topic of change, escapism, and loss are major discussion points of the anime.
I think one’s love for this anime can be probably described in a major aspect of the narrative: asynchronous. Many time cards are shown to assist in the understanding of when and where each event happened. Many find this type of non-linear narrative annoying and frustrating. Those who do will absolutely lose their mind watching Boogiepop Phantom as the same event’s outcome reflect through the eyes of many different individuals. Those that aren’t likely will find the anime entertaining and enjoyable.
As mentioned previously, the narrative takes a vignette form. Virtually every episode will introduce a new character (and some with multiple introductions per episode), give them a full history, and then end their arc. This makes it pretty much impossible for me to discuss the characters as I traditionally do.
What I will say however is that the character roster is deep, round, and varied. One of the greatest aspects of the anime is the strong ensemble cast; motivation, characterization, and result vary greatly. This depth and broadness plays in an incredible manner as many viewers will find their own issues reflected onto them. I find this even more meaningful in today’s world where the topic of escapism via medium is becoming larger and larger. In many regards, the darkest aspects of such topics will come out. One could read it as a partial deconstruction as it reflects how these traits and supernatural events don’t mix…at all.
To some level, I suspect most viewers will find a character to attach themselves to.
One will notice the “washed out” palette right away. The entire world is painted in brown, grey, and black to a large degree. Many shots are night shots. It’s not like this is just an unconscious choice either as the final episode takes this out completely and gives an episode in traditional anime colours. The second effect will be the faded and faux projector effects to the border of the screen. While both are intentional for reasons you’ll likely figure out later in the anime, they are very interesting effects to the animation and will make it stand out in your collection because of the dull colouring.
A major aspect that really intrigues me about Boogiepop Phantom is the fairly realistic character design in animation. Anime has a large tradition of having characters with outrageous hairstyles and hair colour. Boogiepop Phantom averts that nearly completely. For the most part hair colour, hairstyle, and eye colour will reflect what one would expect in any given high school. Few anime avert these traditional tropes this completely and will stand out for this reason as well.
Now, the above comes as both a positive and a negative though. On the positive, it is unique. Extremely so because anime loves utilizing unusual hair colours and styles to their largest effect. However, I will also note that it becomes sometimes difficult to separate and distinguish characters. On first view, I didn’t make every connection possible because I often visually identify characters…in particular, the last episode when the colour scheme becomes more vibrant.
The animation can be brutal at times. What little combat exists is done swiftly. Action is fast paced but short-lived. And this isn’t even going to the horror aspect of the anime which can be very, very graphic. One particularly gory scene has body parts of a recently killed individual. And the body parts shift during transport. Blood rarely appears in the anime but when it does it’s used to its most unsettling effect. And common jump scares with utterly creepy characters are utilized at least once.
One complaint I’ll lob at the animation is its love of characters facing away from the camera. Action will typically occur but in a 2000 anime, it can get distracting when characters don’t face the camera.
I mentioned before that the sound director, Yota Tsuruoka, has an extremely prolific career and has led major anime sound. He makes absolutely no mistake here. The soundtrack to Boogiepop Phantom is incredible. I think for about 9 of the 12 episodes I have a note regarding the use of sound editing or effective background music. It is electric or techno at its core but it is top-notch. They punctuate scenes extremely well and will set the tone in regard to mystery, action, horror, climax, and anything in between. I’m amazed at how many of the soundtracks made their way into my favourites. If you’re on the border, please watch Boogiepop Phantom purely for this. I don’t know any other anime which utilizes so many different effects and subtle shifts (such as those in conversation loudness) to such an effect. Even the void of white noise is utilized (though given that Tsuruoka worked on Lain, this isn’t a huge shock).
The opening, Evening Showers, feels a bit out-of-place. In fact, I think the entire opening is a bit odd as a selection since all it does is introduce the primary characters. Though given the anime, I can kind of see why. It still feels dated by at least 15 years from production though…so today it feels fairly old. The closing, Mirai Seiki Maruhi Club, plays a much more integrated role and feels much more appropriate as a theme for the anime overall on most occasions.
The anime’s subs and dubs are both fairly effective. Dubs primarily consist of a “greatest hits” of the ’90s in the primary and important characters. Crispin Freeman, Rachel Lillis, and Lisa Ortiz all make appearances. I have a slight preference to the sub with exception of one character (Saki Yoshizawa) but I think both are possible options. My suggestion is probably pick whichever you like more. A major issue in either language is the number of voice actors though…there certainly wasn’t enough of a budget to offer top billing voices for every character and some in both languages are a bit lacking.
I think mystery and psychology holds the anime together. It pulls together character design, art choices, and music. The pull of what’s happening in story and to each character causes you to come in. Each of the above elements enforces that and pushes you along that direction. The depth of the character’s perspective and horror elements keep the episode sharp and punctuated. And you leave with a question about how each character really became what they are.
Why to Watch
Boogiepop Phantom is an anime I could recommend for many reasons. If you love mystery, watch it. If you want something with a little thinking involved and won’t lose its narrative novelty on first pass, watch it. If you love psychologically interesting characters…you know what I’ll say. What it comes down to is the fact that Boogiepop Phantom is great at what it intended. The characters with backgrounds have unique and interesting reasons for their existence…though sometimes flimsy. The sound editing is amazing. Suspense and tension all work.
Let’s just leave it at this: if you liked any of the positives in the full review, watch Boogiepop Phantom. Or, inversely, look below and if you don’t see a reason to NOT watch, watch it. I mean, all subbed episodes are available legally on YouTube and two dubbed episodes exist.
Why Not to Watch
The problem with the “Why to Watch” section, of course, is that this also implies a quite unfortunate inverse situation…this anime isn’t good if you aren’t interested in its primary elements. This anime, at best, has limited action. If you want that, you’re out of luck here. If you want something uplifting and positive on a continual basis, it isn’t going to happen. If you want to follow a single character, this is the furthest thing from. Heck, if you like vibrant colours, this isn’t going to happen. If you don’t want a little background work to do first (or just read the above comment in the story section), you should move on unless you want to lose out on part of the narrative. None of these points work out well for the anime though, again, it seems there is little focus here to begin with.
I think I was born to watch this anime. It contains virtually everything I want and doesn’t have things I don’t want. I love psychologically heavy anime. Introducing characters every episode made a lot of fun as it let me explore more characters than most anime let me. I’m not sure there’s a better way to describe it…the anime and I get along very well in focus.
Boogiepop Phantom is anime set out to continue its unique narrative style in animated form. And in that regard, it does that very well. It uses a vignette style narrative to follow a story and connect two of its light novels. Heavy on psychology, suspense, mystery, and character mentality sharing, it emphasizes the key points of the light novels. Viewers interested in these points will have a great experience I believe. Conversely, having no interest in these traits will make the anime tedious at best.
Boogiepop Phantom ended with 7.89/10 for me. Given I use 5 as average, this ranks as a great anime and it currently ranks one of my favourite overall. The single number may not reflect it but Boogiepop Phantom is one of the most interesting and unique anime I know of and highlights a major flaw in using a single value to reflect quality.
The show highly excelled in most regards but had its highest score in characters. There is a strong and diverse cast of characters to understand and learn. Many change within the span of a single episode to reasonable levels. The only stat below a 7 out of 10 is music and vocals. This again reflects a major limitation as this number entitles the incredible background music but also the voice actors who do a good but not exceptional job.